Infrared vs Santa Maria Grills: Which Fits Your Backyard Cookouts?

ByJohn White
Share

An infrared steak grill and a Santa Maria style grill offer two different ways to spend an evening outdoors. One focuses on intense radiant searing; the other centers on managing a fire and adjusting the grate above it.

Both deserve consideration for backyard cookouts. The better fit depends on what you cook, how involved you want to be, and the equipment you already own.

Choose Infrared When Searing Is the Priority

A top-down infrared broiler is worth comparing if steak is a regular part of your menu and you want a dedicated searing tool. Review the cooking area, rack adjustment, fuel requirements, and space around the appliance.

Big Horn Outdoors 16-inch infrared steak grill shown with food
The Big Horn infrared steak grill uses a top-down heating format.

The Big Horn portable infrared steak grill uses propane and top-down infrared heat. Its role may be especially appealing if you already own equipment for gentler cooking and are considering a separate finishing station.

Judge that purchase by your routine. If you rarely cook foods that benefit from searing, a specialized appliance may get less use than a grill suited to a wider range of your usual meals.

Choose Santa Maria When You Enjoy Managing Fire

A Santa Maria style grill puts fuel management and grate position at the center of the experience. That approach suits cooks who enjoy watching the fire develop and moving food as conditions change.

The Argentine Santa Maria Style Grill includes mechanical height adjustment for the cooking grate. Compare its footprint and operating requirements with the outdoor area you have available.

This style may appeal if cooking is the main event and you want to spend time at the grill. Think honestly about whether that involvement is something you enjoy or something you would prefer to simplify.

Compare the Cooking Experience

  • Heat management: Compare the infrared model’s controls and rack positions with the Santa Maria model’s grate adjustment and fire management.
  • Fuel routine: Decide whether propane operation or preparing and tending a solid-fuel fire better fits your plans.
  • Menu: Consider the foods you cook repeatedly and how much usable grate space they need.
  • Time at the grill: Choose the level of involvement you want during an ordinary weeknight or weekend.

Think About Your Whole Outdoor Setup

You may be replacing an old grill, adding a second appliance, or furnishing a cooking area for the first time. Those situations call for different priorities.

Big Horn Outdoors Argentine Santa Maria Style Grill
Compare the Santa Maria grill’s size and grate adjustment with your cooking plans.

If you already have a general-purpose grill, ask what capability you want to add. If this is your first outdoor appliance, consider your full menu rather than choosing around a single impressive dish.

Measure the available space and plan for food preparation, serving, fuel storage, and cleaning. Follow the manual’s clearances instead of treating the product footprint as the total space required.

Questions to Ask Before Ordering

What comes in the exact package? What fuel and tools will you need? How will you clean the removable parts? Where will you store the cooled appliance? Check those answers alongside the current price.

Also read the instructions for heat adjustment before your first cook. Avoid relying on a fixed cooking time or surface appearance alone to judge when food is ready.

Find the Grill That Fits Your Routine

Choose infrared if focused searing is the capability you want to add. Choose Santa Maria style if tending a fire and adjusting the grate are part of your ideal cookout. Explore both in the Fall Sale and compare the exact models before deciding.

Shop the Big Horn Outdoors Fall Sale →

More to Read

Gas Pizza Oven Fuel Consumption Calculator: Measure Real Session Cost A useful gas pizza oven fuel consumption calculator starts with fuel actually used, not a guess based only on maximum burner output. Weighing the p... Gas Pizza Oven Low Pressure in Cold Weather: A Safe Diagnostic Guide Gas pizza oven low pressure in cold weather may show up as a weak flame, slow preheat, falling floor temperature, or poor recovery between pizzas. ... Gas Pizza Oven Left- and Right-Side Hot Spots: Build a Heat Map Gas pizza oven left-side and right-side hot spots come from the interaction of burner geometry, flame path, walls, floor, opening, preheat, wind, a...